Should your Doctor determine if you get Social Security Disability or SSI?
Ideally, a social security disability or SSI claimant's doctor (treating physician) should determine whether or not a claimant is awarded disability benefits. After all, this is the same individual who is responsible for monitoring and treating the patient and who is in the best possible position to determine the prognosis and functional outlook (social security disability eligibility always hinges on functionality, i.e. whether or not a person can perform work activity) of the patient.
However, if this was the case, then the social security administration would no longer need nearly as many disability examiners who work on reconsideration appeals nor as many judges who render decisions at the hearing level. Because so many more correct decisions would be rendered at the disability application level, making the need for appeals far less.
Here's why it will never be the case that social security disability decisions will rest on the opinions of treating physicians.
A. The social security administration has an inherent distrust of personal doctors.
B. The social security administration has the unstated goal of keeping the number of disability approvals down.
Regarding A, I speak from the position of being a former examiner and as someone involved in disability representation. The simple truth is that a detailed supportive statement from a doctor at a disability hearing can make or break a case, while the same letter when viewed at the disability application or request for reconsideration appeal level may be all but ignored. Why the difference between the two? Because decisions that are made at the first two levels of the system are made by disability examiners and examiners are tightly controlled by their supervisors. In other words, the social security disability and SSI system keeps a close rein on how many approvals these examiners make (chiefly through the threat of external quality control, which tends to focus on approved cases, not denied cases).
Hearing level decisions, by contrast, are made by independent federal administrative law judges. I've actually heard disability examiners and field office claims reps complain about the number of approvals made by these judges and make statements along the lines of "that decision would never have been made by an examiner" or "those judges make crazy decisions". However, the decisions issued by judges tend to be better, because judges do not have supervisors and are free to render decisions as they personally see fit. And, perhaps, because they do function independently, disability judges give far more credence to the opinions of treating physicians.
Regarding B, does the social security administration attempt to keep approvals on cases down? I think the numbers speak for themselves. Seventy percent of disability applications are denied by disability examiners. Of those individuals who are denied and decide to file a request for reconsideration an even higher percentage of 85 percent are denied. Yet, of those who persist and go to the hearing level, more than half are eventually approved.
Why weren't these cases approved at the very beginning of the disability process? Because the disability system is, sadly and unfortunately, set up to discourage claimants. And, yes, this does work. Thousands of individuals who are denied never appeal. They give up. This, of course, is something a claimant should never do. Because the odds of being approved lie in the claimant's favor...if they simply refuse to give up and follow the appeals process.
Return to the Social Security Disability SSI Benefits Blog
Long Term Disability, Social Security Disability, and Offset
Social Security Disability SSI and Hyperthyroidism
Social Security Disability Mistakes
Can you get Disability if you are unemployable?
Disability and heart failure
Social Security Disability and Lowered IQ
Schizophrenia Social Security Disability SSI - Applying for Disability
How many Social Security Disability and SSI cases are Backlogged in the System?
Can you Say the Wrong thing at a Social Security Disability CE examination?
Sjogren's Syndrome Social Security Disability SSI - Applying for Disability
If I Receive an Inheritance, will I lose my Disability Payments?
Social Security Disability Residual Functional Capacity Form
Quality Reviews of SSD Cases
Fibromyalgia Patients, Lyrica, and Social Security Disability
Social Security Disability Claims in Atlanta Georgia
Social Security Disability Ticket to Work Program
What's the Worst Social Security Disability Hearing Office in the Country?
Question about SSI back pay after being approved
Why are Living Arrangements Addressed During an SSI Application?
Sixty Days before you Can Reapply for Disability?
When Should a Disability Attorney take Your case?
Social Security Disability Activities of Daily Living Questionaire
Social Security Administration Concedes it will be undermanned, turns to Technology
Get a Good Disability Attorney or Disability Representative
Social Security Disability and Past Work (the relevant period)
Bipolar Disorder, On Medical Leave, When should you file for disability?
How can I Win my Social Security Disability Case Without Going to a Hearing?
The 24 month Waiting Period and Social Security Disability
Can you Receive Disability Benefits and have Assets, Investments, a Savings Account?
Steps for Filing a Request for a Social Security Disability Hearing (and tips)
Can a Younger Person Qualify for Disability Benefits?
Children and Child Disability Claims
Applying for Disability for a Child - gathering records
Problems in Winning a Disability Case for a Child
Social Security Disability - Why do I need to see my doctor regularly when my doctor can't help me?
Social Security Appeals Online
Aneurysm - should I file for disability?
What does a Disability Lawyer Charge if the Disability Case is Lost?
What is a Qualifying Disability for Social Security?
What if you receive a Denial at a Disability Hearing?
Once you are approved for SSD are minor children automatically approved for SSI?
Why Most SS Disability Claims are Denied
Physician Support for Your Social Security Disability Case
Doctor Records and the Social Security Disability Hearing